Issue
You have asked for our opinion whether the misapplied funds from a dedicated account
by a representative payee are a legal debt for purposes of bankruptcy proceedings.
Short Answer
For the reasons set forth below, we believe that SSA's right to recovery of misapplied
funds from a representative payee means the funds are a debt for purposes of bankruptcy.
Legal Analysis
Section 1631(a)(2)(F) of the Social Security Act, 42 U.S.C. § 1383(a)(2)(F), requires
that the representative payee for a child under age 18 establish a separate account
with a financial institution, i.e., a dedicated account, where the child is entitled
to more than six months past-due benefits. See 20 C.F.R. §§ 416.542(a)(3), 416.546, 416.640(e). The law specifies that the funds
may be used only for medical treatment, education or job training, or for other expenses,
provided they are related to the child's impairment. See id. at 416.640(e)(2). Use of funds from a dedicated account in any manner not specifically
authorized "shall be considered a misapplication of benefits . . . and any representative
payee who knowingly misapplies benefits from such an account shall be liable to the
Commissioner in an amount equal to the total amount" expended. Id. § 1383(a)(2)(F)(ii); see also id. at 416.640(e); POMS SI 02101.010 (Past-Due Benefits Payable-Individual Under Age 18 with Representative Payee-Dedicated
Account Required); GN 00602.140 (Permitted Expenditures from Dedicated Accounts).[_11]
As explained in POMS GN 00602.140B.5:
"Misapplication" of benefits occurs when a payee knowingly uses dedicated account
funds for expenditures not permitted. (Misapplication differs from misuse in that
misuse occurs when a payee uses funds for a purpose other than for the use and benefit
of the beneficiary, while the misapplication of funds, though not permitted, can benefit
the beneficiary. In addition, misapplied funds that are returned go back to the General
Revenues, while misused funds that are returned go back to the dedicated account.
See GN 00602.140C.8.) A determination of misapplication is an initial determination, with appeal rights.
[See POMS GN 00602.150D.3.b. Procedures for making misapplication determinations are in GN 00602.140C.
When SSA "determines that a payee 'knowingly' misapplied funds," the Agency will attempt
to collect the total misapplied amount from the payee as provided in POMS GN 00602.150. POMS GN 00602.140B.5.a. The process for collecting from the payee is described in POMS GN 00602.150D. The payee has 60 days after notification of the misapplication determination to request
reconsideration. If the payee requests reconsideration, SSA must stop recovery efforts.
SSA may resume recovery efforts after the reconsideration determination and continue
collection efforts, even if the payee pursues further administrative appeal remedies,
i.e., requests a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge or Appeals Council review.
See POMS GN 00602.150D.3.b. If the payee fails to respond to the initial determination within 60 days or refuses
to cooperate or repay, the case may be referred to the Department of Justice (DOJ)
for civil action. See POMS GN 00602.150D. If referral to DOJ is not appropriate or DOJ declines to take the case, the file
is annotated and the Office of Financial Policy and Planning Operations must be notified.
See id.
Under 11 U.S.C. § 101 (12) of the Bankruptcy Code, "'debt' means liability on a claim."
Section 101(5) defines a "claim" as
(A) right to payment, whether or not such right is reduced to judgment, liquidated,
unliquidated, fixed, contingent, matured, unmatured, disputed, undisputed, legal,
equitable, secured, or unsecured; or
(B) right to an equitable remedy for breach of performance if such breach gives rise
to a right to payment, whether or not such right to an equitable remedy is reduced
to judgment, fixed, contingent, matured, unmatured, disputed, undisputed, secured,
or unsecured[.]
Based on the foregoing, we believe that because SSA has a right to recover misapplied
funds from the representative payee, the misapplication of funds constitutes a debt
as defined in the Bankruptcy Code.
The filing of a bankruptcy petition results in an automatic stay of collection activity
with respect to the debtor or any contingently liable person, but not to any other
jointly and severally liable person who is not a party to the bankruptcy action. See POMS GN 02215.185. Therefore, where SSA is collecting or attempting to collect misapplied funds from
a representative payee who has filed a bankruptcy petition, SSA should stop all collection
efforts and proceed under the relevant POMS provisions pertaining to bankruptcy.
CONCLUSION
For the reasons discussed above, we believe that misapplied funds are legal debt subject
to the bankruptcy rules.
Deana R. E~-L~
Regional Chief Counsel, Region VIIIBy ___________________
Teresa H. A~
Assistant Regional Counsel
_11It might also be possible to find that the payee misused the funds, and "a finding
of misuse does not preclude a finding that the payee also misapplied funds." POMS
GN 00602.140C.8.d. In the case of misuse, POMS GN 00604.045 and GN 00604.050 apply.