If the Appeals Council (AC) remands a case to the hearing level
after a court remand, it generally vacates the entire administrative
law judge (ALJ) decision, and the ALJ must consider all pertinent issues
de novo.
If the AC remands a partially
favorable decision to the hearing level after a court remand,
the ALJ must only consider the unfavorable portion of the
decision. Thus, the ALJ's decision should contain language
noting the limited time period. While the favorable portion
of the partially favorable decision is not before the ALJ,
the entire decision is subject to reopening under 20
CFR 404.988 and 416.1488.
When the AC vacates an ALJ decision in an initial entitlement
case, the AC will usually direct that the ALJ offer the claimant an
opportunity for a hearing and issue a new decision in the case. The
ALJ will generally decide the remanded issues through the date of
the new hearing decision or, in title II cases involving an expired
date last insured, through the date of last insured status. When
appropriate, the ALJ may issue a recommended decision. See Hearings,
Appeals, and Litigation Law (HALLEX) manual HA 01280.015.
The claimant may appeal an ALJ's decision after a
court remand by filing written exceptions within 30 days of
the date of the ALJ's decision (or within the time allowed by
the AC after permitting an extension of time). See 20
CFR 404.984(b) and 416.1484(b).
See also HALLEX HA 01480.020. Additionally, the AC may assume
jurisdiction of the ALJ's decision under its own motion authority within
60 days of the date of the ALJ's decision. See 20
CFR 404.969 and 416.1469,
and HALLEX HA 01360.001.
If the ALJ determines
that the criteria for a dismissal are present, the ALJ will
follow the instructions in HALLEX HA 01240.037. However, when the case
was remanded by the court under sentence six of sections
205(g) and 1631(c) of the Social Security Act, an ALJ may not dismiss
the request for hearing even when the usual dismissal criteria are
present. Rather, the ALJ will issue a decision. See HALLEX
HA 01240.037.